I have come to be quite skeptical
of the way wind power is being sold. I’ve come to agree with much of what
Jonathan Carter, executive director of the Forest Ecology Network, now believes
about mountaintop wind power, after decades of touting it:
No fossil-fuel power plant has ever
been closed because of wind power, and probably never will, given the unreliability
and intermittent nature of wind.
Indeed, reserve plants may need to
be built to provide back-up if dependence on wind grows.
Fossil-fuel plants need to be
cycled down when wind capacity is high, thus increasing their already poor
efficiency ratings and actually increasing CO2 emission.
Mountaintops must be cleared of
trees, roads built, power lines installed, thus removing carbon-sequestering
forests and increasing emissions.
Electricity produced by wind costs
2-3 times as much as conventional power.
There are also huge subsidies from
tax dollars, the main reason wind farms are being built today.
Wind farms produce a few temporary
jobs but almost no permanent ones.
Home values drop in the vicinity of
a turbine.
Ill effects of noise, low-frequency
sound waves, and “shadow flicker,” and the economic impact on tourism, have not
been completely studied.
Finally, what about esthetic
values, not just for tourism and the effect on pristine mountains, but for
themselves? Is it worth it?
Maine is exactly where we should be having the debate. Take
Monhegan, for example, where gritty artists George Bellows and Edward Hopper
might have enjoyed huge metal beasts but perhaps not more ethereal Jamie Wyeth
and Rockwell Kent, where thousands of people seek tranquility and escape from
electricity. How would the artists and nature lovers coming to this natural
heaven on earth deal with an artificial thing standing 400 feet tall, gently
roaring? Would they take their easels and money belts elsewhere? Or would they,
we, all accept that this is the price of progress? Maine trades on its beauty and undefiled
landscapes as much as anywhere on earth; are we just going to roll over to the
demands of the grid? What few people question is the need for all these
machines in the first place.
Excerpted from Saving
Maine: A Personal Gazetteer